Forumsee logo
Forumsee » Photography » Cameras and Equipment » Read message
RSS: Subscribe to RSS

Nifty fifty STM - focus issues, or human error?

Canon Lenses - www.thephotoforum.com
I have a question for users experienced with fast primes. Today, I tried to test AF with my 700D (T5i) and my two lenses:

- EF-S 18-55mm 3.5-5.6 IS STM

- EF 50mm 1.8 STM

I noticed an issue with the 50mm. When I open up the aperture to the max, the AF jumps a bit on every other photo.

But here's the catch - when I put the camera to Live View, and focus using contrast-detect only, the focus is nailed every single time. But the moment I revert to phase-detect, the focus jumps every few photos. This was never an issue with my 18-55 lens.

After shooting wide-open, I matched the parameters of 50mm to 18-55 ones - that is, I selected 5.6 aperture (because 5.6 is max on 18-55 at the telephoto end). Phase-detect focusing improved significantly.

My question - is 50mm supposed to jump focus when wide-open? Why it doesn't jump when using contrast-detect?

Note that my camera doesn't have micro-AF adjustment, and doesn't have dual-pixel AF. It uses an old-school 9-point, all cross-type sensor (probably from 60D). I've noticed that phase-detect AF takes more time if set to apertures larger than 3.5.

Testing parameters:

- 700D and 50mm 1.8 STM, subject = a row of books

- global settings = 2 sec delay, wide-open, center AF point (dual cross-type), tripod

- first test with phase-detect, 4 shots, viewfinder = two shots good, two bad

- second test with contrast-detect, 4 shots, Live View, electronic 1st curtain = all good

When using phase-detect, it goes like this (note that camera and subject never moved):

- half press > focused > full press > countdown > shot

- half press > focus jumps > full press > countdown > shot

So is it okay, or should I replace my lens? Is it lens, or camera issue? Few days ago I took a photo of my brother, but it was out of focus (lens was wide-open). I tried to be as still as possible, yet the photo wasn't sharp.

But if we cannot use the widest aperture, what's the point of having it on the lens? Do I really have to resort to contrast-detect Live View to get sharp photos on 1.8? Or is it just how fast primes work? Yes, I know that DoF is very thin, but the camera was on tripod. Most people praise this lens, and I sincerely hope it won't be a big issue during real-life use.

 


Read responses in thephotoforum.com

Tags


Last videos:

4K 60P and Slow Motion
4K 60P and Slow Motion
I'm a YouTube Poet
I'm a YouTube Poet
Happy Holidays, from an Airport
Happy Holidays, from an Airport
Printing Tutorials
Printing Tutorials
Sony a7R III
Sony a7R III
HSS and Flash Meters
HSS and Flash Meters
Documentaries on LF photography
Documentaries on LF photography
4K 60p Panasonic GH5 thread
4K 60p Panasonic GH5 thread
Cars · 
Mobility · 
Hardware · 
Motorbikes · 
Travel · 
Boating · 
Aviation · 
production-frontend
About Forumsee · Contact · Privacy policy · Request content removal
We use cookies for navigation analysis and personalized advertisement. By using our site, you agree to our use of cookies.
Accept  ·  Learn more